I often use the terms unintentional and intentional. From a safety perspective, human error is a possibility but you can train people not to make errors. Setting norms and standards inform the approach to training people and good training reduces human error. You want to make sure that the aeroplane maintenance is good to avoid accidents.
AvSec is a newer discipline to the security community. In the security domain, you can have preventive measures but the perpetrator is always intentional. Outside threats which want to harm your organisation intentionally, find ways around these measures. By applying a risk-based approach you understand that you cannot always take away the risk because the intention is present. Robust aviation security management lowers the risk and anticipates.
Currently, aviation is focused solely on COVID-19. The topic is omnipresent also in the debate about security, yet it diverts attention from existing threats. Focusing only on COVID-19 means we will lose awareness of other perpetrators like terrorist organisations. For example, Foreign Affairs travel advisories use colour codes to assess a destination’s risk level. Nowadays, the colour often represents a COVID-related issue, the traveller misinterprets the actual story and other threats in the advisory are being neglected. There again is the misperception of health safety risk vs. security risk.
While there has not been a major terrorist attack using aviation as a tool, global events show us that the insecurity in the world is only increasing. We have unstable regimes, terrorist organisations wanting to attack Western society could use aviation as means. We are not in a safe environment and people tend to look away.
From my background in security services, I know the threats to aviation and it was my job to raise awareness so an organisation can take measures and create a security policy. It will be the big thing for the next couple of years to refocus on the other threats and initiate a change of mind for proper contingency planning.
My lessons learnt are: talk to the stakeholders, be in touch with the stakeholders. Not only between the walls of organisations, but to actively share intelligence. Knowing your partner's mutual security measures encourages cooperation between stakeholders without compromising the information and mission.
In my opinion, cyber is indeed a real threat to the aviation industry and it would be difficult to deny this. Terrorists and those who want to attack the industry may be deemed to be one step ahead and this is why as an industry we should have a preventive approach rather than a reactive approach. And this is even more so because aviation will always be an appealing target for those who want to attack.
Secondly, build a security culture to ensure that everyone within the organisations knows why security is needed. The understanding and appreciation of security should become a fact that can be fostered through a top-down approach – management needs to make sure that everybody thinks about security, including themselves. Management also needs to make budgets available, raise awareness, train the organisation.
Besides robust internal policies, the focus of capacitating and enabling lays in cooperation with others. Share your intelligence to build your own network so that appropriate measures during crisis management can be taken. This partner approach goes beyond any standard operating procedure (SOPs) because not every manual can accommodate different situations. Instead of looking up the SOP, you need to be able to know who to call first to get the information. Against the assumptions that intelligence organisations sit on their information value, I try to teach awareness to tell your partners and recommend sharing the information as part of the crisis management.
Your organisation needs to develop its own strategy of security policies, put them in place and not be limited by the mandates of ICAO, EASA, etc. Robust security management includes risk management, contingency readiness and quality assurance. Audit your policy to see how it affects the organisation. The following mindset is also important: in risk management, you cannot solve the problem. There will always be a residual risk. The training helps organisations to develop the mindset to draft the right policy papers and how to work with those threats in the risk management model. Once you are aware of the threats, you have a professional eye for the right measures that can prevent countless incidents.
A common financial motivation is that if nothing happens, budgets can be cut. But it is because of these deterrents that the organisation and its environment are safe. Organisational security should not be a rule-driven necessity, as a preventive measure to protect people, the organisation, its assets, and its reputation.
So for training and consultancy organisations, we have to raise awareness. Telling people why security is needed, why security culture can protect reputation. Working in security is sharing incidents from other organisation or countries from which learnings and improvements can be derived. Establishing robust systems allows one to anticipate threats, manage risk and launch countermeasures. Through practical training, we can develop the security mindset for managers and expand their receptiveness to the right security policies.
About JAA Training Organisation ✈
The JAA Training Organisation (JAA TO) is a Dutch non-profit organisation and the Associated Body of the European Civil Aviation Conference (ECAC). JAA TO has a history of 50+ years training the aviation industry and national authorities on regulation in the air transport sector. JAA TO is the only Platinum Training Centre of Excellence (TCE) in Europe recognised by the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO). JAA TO is an IATA Dangerous Goods CBTA Centre of Excellence, an ACI World Accredited Training Partner, recognized Dutch National Aviation Security Training Centre and a leading member of the EASA Virtual Academy (EVA).
JAA TO schedules more than 300 training courses annually on topics such as safety, security, drones and management. Within the aviation community, JAA TO offers a platform to learn and exchange views on latest regulatory developments. In addition, JAA TO provides advisory services, knowledge solutions, training consultancy and assistance with capacity building for (aviation) training departments.
